Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

Share:Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Tweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someonePrint this page
The Good The Bad The Bottom Line
Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

Brita Pitcher Filter

System & Filters Are Inexpensive Very Short Filter Life A Good Way to Remove Common Contaminants
Aquasana-Powered-Water-Filt

Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System

Filters Over 60 Contaminants System & Replacement Filters are Expensive A Powerful Water Filtration System
Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle with Carbon Filter

Good Filter Life. Ensures Great Tasting Water Has to be Used with a Water Cooler A Good Filter for Clean Drinking Water

In 2009, Gallup asked over 1000 Americans what they thought the biggest environmental problem they were facing. Though everyone expressed concern about global warming, rain forests, and air pollution, their number one concern was polluted drinking water. Fifty-nine percent of everyone surveyed said they worried about it a great deal and this may explain the growing popularity of home water filters. Water never comes into your home pure and untouched. It always retains traces of the chemicals used in water treatment plants, not to mention minerals or deposits from your city’s water pipes. Water filters protect you from these contaminants and allow you to enjoy pure, clean drinking water, like you’d find in nature.

Even though there are more water filters than ever to choose from, it’s actually harder than ever to decide which one will provide the drinking water you need. Is it a whole house filter? A reverse osmosis filter? An under counter filter? A faucet attach filter? All of these require a significant amount of time and energy to install, so what if what you need is a water filtration system that you can buy and set up in just a couple of minutes? There are only two that meet that criteria: pitcher water filters and the NewAir water bottle filter. They’re inexpensive, easy-to-use, and simple to set up. If you’re not familiar with the benefits do they provide compared to one another, we examined two of the most popular water pitcher filters against the NewAir water bottle, to see how they stacked up.

Water Filter Criteria

We judged each filter using three criteria. We wanted to know:

  1. How well does it work?
  2. How long does it last?
  3. How much water does it hold?
  4. How much does it cost?

Each criterion plays an important role in determining whether each system will be the best, long-term fit for your home.

How Well Does Each Water Filter Work?

Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

Brita Filter Pitcher

The Brita Filter Pitcher has a granulated carbon filter (also known as activated carbon) that targets four pollutants: copper, cadmium, mercury, and lead. It also eliminates the taste and odor of chlorine. Granulated carbon is one of the simplest and most straight-forward filtration methods. It’s made from carbonaceous material that has been baked at extremely high heat until its structure dissolves into individual carbon granules. Wood, coal, peat, nutshells, and coconuts are some of the most common materials used to make it. Carbon granules are small but extremely porous. Less than an ounce of them has a combined surface area of over 5400 square feet, due to its extensive network of microscopic nooks and crannies. They act as traps that capture small particles and chemical deposits. Because carbon can be packed into very small spaces, carbon filters are commonly found in small, compact filter systems, like Brita Filter Pitchers. The one downside to carbon is that it isn’t as good at filtering out heavy metals as it is as filtering chemicals. If you live in an areas with a high level of metal contamination, quite a bit of it could get through.

Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System
The Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System is without a doubt the most powerful personal water filter you can buy. It uses a specialized filter called Claryum, which is only available through Aquasana. Claryum filters combine four different filtration methods: activated carbon, catalytic carbon, ion-exchange, and a sub-micron filter. Catalytic carbon is granulated carbon that has been treated with a catalyst that dissolves chemicals in your water supply. An ion-exchange filter uses small beads that have been coated with an ion-resin to attract and eliminate inorganic molecules, like metal, from your water supply. Harmful molecules are drawn in and attach to the surface of the beads, sending out another ion to replace it (hence ion-exchange). This method is extremely effective at filtering dangerous metals like lead or cadmium, but ineffective against bacteria and other parasites. They’re trapped by Claryum’s sub-micron filter, which blocks particles down to 0.1 microns, 500 times smaller than the width of a human hair. It targets organic material the other filters may have missed, such as asbestos and microbes like cryptosporidium or giardia. In total, Aquasana’s filter can remove over 60 different contaminants and pollutants, far more than any other pitcher filter on the market.

Aquasana enhances its filtration process with a small motor in the base of the pitcher that forces the water through the filter, so it’s ready to drink in only a few seconds. Most pitcher filers rely on gravity to pull the water down through the filter, which is slow and can take several minutes.

NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle
The filter in the NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle is very similar to Brita’s. It has a single granulated carbon filter and the water inside percolates through the filter as it’s pulled down by gravity. The filter removes the taste and odor of chlorine. It also eliminates sediment and volatile organic compounds, such as chlorinated solvents and fuels, which can seep into groundwater. In most areas, these are the most common pollutants you’ll find in your tap water. Drinking water is heavily regulated by the EPA. Metals, asbestos, and biological parasites are normally removed in water treatment plants before the water is sent out to your home. For most households, a heavy-duty filter like Aquasana’s is excessive. Most of the pollutants it removes have already been reduced far below the level where they might pose a threat to human health and a granulated carbon filter can eliminate the rest at a fraction of the cost.

How Long Does Each Filter Last?

Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

Brita Filter Pitcher
The Brita Filter Pitcher has a very short filter life. It’s only effective for about 2 months and can filter about 40 gallons of water before it needs to be replaced. To reduce the inconvenience caused by dead filters, Brita has installed WI-FI technology on their Brita Infinity Water Pitcher. It connects with your WI-FI router and automatically alerts online retailers like Amazon whenever your filter needs to be replaced. The retailer creates an order and the replacement filter arrives on your doorstep a few days later, saving you the hassle of ordering it yourself.

Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System
The Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System can filter approximately 320 gallons of water before the filter has to be replaced, normally once every 6 months.

NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle
The filter in the NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle can filter approximately 211 gallons of water and has to be replaced roughly every 6 months as well, depending on how much you use it.

How Much Water Does Each Container Hold?

Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle FilterBrita Filter Pitcher
The storage capacity of Brita Filter Pitchers varies depending on the model you buy. The smallest is the slim, which holds 5 cups, or about a third of a gallon of water. The largest, the Everyday and the Grand, hold 10 cups, which is a little over a half gallon.

Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System
Despite its power, the Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System only holds 8 cups of water, about the same as an ordinary Brita pitcher.

NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle
Because the NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle is not designed to be hand-carried (it sits on top of your water cooler) it can hold a lot more water than Brita or Aquasana pitchers. Its storage capacity is 3.04 gallons – 1.3 gallons in the top chamber and 1.7 gallons in the bottom chamber. These figures only refer to the capacity of the bottle itself. The cooler it sits on also has a water reservoir that normally hold 1-1.5 gallons of water, allowing you to keep a lot more drinking water on hand than you could with any water pitcher.

How Much Does Each Filter Cost?

Brita Filter Pitcher
Like its storage capacity, the cost of a Brita Filter Pitcher varies according to size. The cheapest is the Brita Space Saver Water Filter Pitcher, which costs about $11. The most expensive is the Brita Infinity Water Pitcher, which costs about $45. Replacement filters for all the Brita pitchers costs $7.99. If you replace them as often as recommended, they’ll cost you $48 over the course of a year.

Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System
The Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System is significantly more expensive than either Brita or NewAir. The pitcher alone costs $149.99, while the replacement filters cost $29.99.

NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle
Even though it holds more water, the NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle is actually costs about the same as a high-end Brita Pitcher: $45. Replacement filters cost $20. However, there are more costs involved than the bottle and filter. The WAT10W has to be used with a freestanding water dispenser, which typically costs between $100 and $200, depending on what kind you buy.

The Bottom Line

Luke's-Son-WAT10W

If you’re looking to get the maximum amount of clean drinking water for the smallest price, then the NewAir WAT10W Water Bottle is the better choice. It has the largest storage capacity of any personal filtration system for the lowest cost. If you already own a water dispenser, or are planning on buying one, will save you a ton of money in the long run. Instead of refilling the dispenser with bottled water, which costs $1.20-$1.40 per gallon, it lets you filter your tap water, which costs less than $0.01 per gallon.

On the other hand, if you don’t have space for a water cooler or simply don’t want to buy one, you’re probably better off buying a Brita Filter Pitcher rather than the Aquasana Powered Water Filtration System. Even through Aquasana has a more powerful filter, it’s not a necessity for most homes. Water treatment plants have already removed most of the really dangerous contaminants it’s designed to catch. The only exception is areas with poor plumbing and deteriorating pipes, either in your home or in the city’s water system. If this is the case where you live, there is a risk that metal and other harmful substances in the pipes could be absorbed by the water and lead to health problems. Then, a more powerful filtration system like Aquasana would be required. Otherwise, you’re better off sticking with something simpler.

Pitcher Water Filters vs. NewAir Water Bottle Filter

Share:Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Tweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someonePrint this page

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *